Suppose you woke up one day and found yourself attached by tubes to another person, and then you are told that this other person will die if you disconnect the tubes. You, however, will not be injured. Supposed that at no point did you agree to have this other person tethered to you.
Suppose this other person is in a wheel chair. You can get around, but it obviously severely limits your movements.
Do you, as an autonomous human being with your own rights, have the right to disconnect the tubes, therefore causing the other person to die?
What if it was just for an hour?
What if it was for a month?
What about 9 months?
What if the connection was threatening your own health? What if the connection could potentially kill you?
What if this connection could cost you your job? Your family? Your friends?
What if you had to expend major financial expenses to keep this other person alive, to the point that it would bankrupt you?
And before you say anything, I am aware that this is not an exact parallel for abortion. I have my own thoughts on this, but I’m hoping to get some reasonable discussion on it.
~ Steve
-
gotquirks reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback
-
lights-on-fire reblogged this from afunnyfeminist
-
alexandraerin reblogged this from afunnyfeminist
-
afunnyfeminist reblogged this from abaldwin360 and added:
Hypothetical situations could happen. This guy went well beyond posing a hypothetical situation and just threw out a...
-
sovietnarwhal liked this
-
sovietnarwhal reblogged this from maiamorgan
-
thethreelittlesontarans liked this
-
maiamorgan reblogged this from eeeegads
-
cangal liked this
-
firefirewhoa liked this
-
djspins reblogged this from religiousragings and added:
Now try thinking from...directly associated with...couldn’t...
-
kat-actress liked this
-
marmoulak liked this
-
abaldwin360 reblogged this from afunnyfeminist and added:
Well, me for one. I’ve read a lot of hypothetical situations and participated in thought experiments that lead me to...
-
afunnyfeminist reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback and added:
He tried. He failed. He didn’t offer criticism of this ridiculous situation. He just threw it out there to start a...
-
thisthat-and-liberalstuff liked this
-
mashkwi reblogged this from marmoulak and added:
Feminists putting their foot in their mouths, again.
-
rampantlinguist liked this
-
99-luftballons reblogged this from marmoulak and added:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Oe6HUgrRlQ&feature=player_embedded
-
99-luftballons liked this
-
space-kase liked this
-
jezzy-jazz reblogged this from abaldwin360
-
marmoulak reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback and added:
I totally agree. Guys, chill out! This is a great example why the pro-choice, feminist, liberal, agnostic, skeptic, and...
-
ana-coluthia reblogged this from religiousragings and added:
It’s amazing to me how many people don’t realize that two people can have the same thought. I’ve come up with plenty of...
-
vogueflo liked this
-
greekwords reblogged this from bigfatopinions and added:
Reblogging for the last comment.
-
greekwords reblogged this from bigfatopinions
-
greekwords reblogged this from mstashers and added:
let somebody else die. I’d...absolutely could...illegal for...
-
onravenswings liked this
-
dreamfaerye reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback
-
theworldoffabio reblogged this from abaldwin360
-
kafeidotour reblogged this from bigfatopinions
-
bigfatopinions reblogged this from afunnyfeminist and added:
Let me toss something in here as a fellow pro-choice feminist. If you were REALLY about equality, you would NEVER drag...
-
religiousragings reblogged this from thepersonalispolitic and added:
LOL! Did it ever occur to you that two people could come up with similar examples WITHOUT stealing from each other. My...
-
seesawarsaw reblogged this from mstashers
-
thepersonalispolitic reblogged this from mstashers and added:
THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! THE OP STOLE THIS THOUGHT EXPERIMENT! No,...
-
anesthezea liked this
-
dominoblox reblogged this from infinitelyawkwords
-
mstashers liked this
-
mstashers reblogged this from bacon-beer-and-boobs
-
bacon-beer-and-boobs reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback and added:
This is to prove that even if the fetus was sentient, it would still have no right to live off of someone else, and no...
-
kseniajeffrey liked this
-
infinitelyawkwords reblogged this from religiousragings and added:
Worthy of the read.
-
perfectlyqueer reblogged this from thisgingersnapsback
-
bouncingdodecahedrons liked this
-
saynathespiffy liked this
-
thisgingersnapsback reblogged this from patentlywill and added:
No, it’s not. Jesus fucking christ. OP is showing how no one has the right to your body, EVER. That was VERY easy to...
-
thisgingersnapsback reblogged this from afunnyfeminist and added:
…I’d like to understand how trying to make a point that would essentially help change or alter the minds of the people...
-
radishson liked this
-
saynathespiffy reblogged this from afunnyfeminist and added:
Well, yeah, it is pretty shitty. People should just get it. People should have some empathy and actually listen to...
- Show more notes
